Studying pathology is not a fascinating subject for many students. Today, novel educational methods have received attention worldwide. This study aimed to design an oral and maxillofacial pathology learning application and evaluate its effectiveness on dental students’ knowledge of the Isfahan dental faculty.
In this experimental study, after designing a web application, including an oral pathology context (PathoGAME), its effectiveness on 112 junior dental students’ knowledge was investigated in 2022. After introducing the application, students were motivated to use the app for learning oral pathology. They were then examined in the midterm and final examinations. Subsequently, their scores on the questions related to the application’s contents were compared with the scores of other questions. Finally, students’ satisfaction with the application was evaluated. The data were analyzed using SPSS software and paired
In the midterm examination, there was no significant difference between the mean score of questions related or unrelated to the application’s content among those who had used the application. Furthermore, the mean scores of the related questions for the application users and those who did not, were not significantly different (
Overall, novel educational methods, such as this application, were beneficial for improving students’ understanding of pathology. The users’ satisfaction was high in utilizing this application, indicating the application’s success and confirming its feasibility.
Oral diseases are significant health problems at the global level and have both high prevalence and adverse effects on individuals and societies. In general, more than 3.5 billion people around the world suffer from oral diseases.[
The oral cavity must be examined for malignant changes through exact clinical examinations and routine screening. These changes should be easily detected in the early stages to lead to more effective disease management. Despite easy access to the oral cavity for examinations, oral cancer remains a disease with high mortality. Early diagnosis and treatment decrease patient morbidity and mortality; however, most oral cancers are diagnosed at late stages, even in developed countries.[
Patients with oral lesions are often examined by general dentists for the first time; therefore, general dentists play a vital role in diagnosing oral cancers in the early stages.[
Oral pathology is a specialty of dentistry that addresses the diagnosis and management of oral and maxillofacial lesions. The knowledge of pathology bridges the gap between basic and clinical dental science, which is essential in training students to correctly diagnose the cause and mechanisms of oral diseases.[
According to medical science professors and students, this knowledge is considered one of the most challenging subjects in the educational curriculum. Moreover, it is neglected by many dentists because they are not ordinarily involved with oral pathology.[
Considering the technological advances and changes in the digital world in recent decades, the need to change traditional learning methods or to accompany novel methods is expected. In this regard, learning applications are suggested as effective educational tools that engage students in purposeful, entertaining, and motivating activities in a safe environment. In addition, it provides a platform where social interaction and bonding among students are promoted, thus increasing students’ connection with the educational environment and the desired subject.[
An increase in problem-solving skills and critical thinking has been observed through the use of these kinds of applications.[
Similar studies have been conducted on application design and development. In this regard, Kanthan and Senger investigated the effect of the application on learning pathology in students in 2011. In this study, the students’ pathology course grades increased significantly with the use of game-based application training. Moreover, students’ satisfaction, individual learning, and stress reduction were observed.[
Janssen
In another study, Gudadappanavar
Tsopra
By designing an educational application to facilitate learning neurology, Anton Raskurazhev
Despite the effectiveness of the application in the above studies, in the study by Jesse Courtier
Due to the global prevalence of these oral lesions and their impact on individuals’ quality of life, the significance of pathology knowledge for early diagnosis of these lesions, and students’ indifference to studying and learning pathology, it is necessary to utilize novel learning approaches. Therefore, considering the contradictory findings about the impact of educational applications on students’ learning and the limitations of this method in learning oral pathology in Iran and abroad, this study aimed to design and develop an application for teaching oral pathology to dental students to promote the education, diagnosis, and treatment of pathological lesions.
The present quasi-experimental study was conducted in 2022–2023 at the Dentistry Faculty of Isfahan University of Medical Sciences. An application was designed for 112 3rd-year dental students to learn oral pathology.
The protocol was approved with the number IR.MUI.RESEARCH.REC.1401.171 by the Ethics and Research Committee of Isfahan University of Medical Sciences.
In the design of this application, called PathoGAME, three exercises were assigned to each lesion separately. The questions designed in this application are in English. The design and completion of this application were performed within 4 months by a software engineering specialist.
Before accessing the exercises, users are prompted to sign in through the sign-in page, which ensures secure and personalized access to the application [
Sign-in page of the application.
After completing the first exercise, the second and third exercises are activated. In addition, the application design allows the user to access more exercises by choosing the fourth exercise. Five separate stages are considered for each exercise [
Stages of application using mobile device
23 The first stage consists of 4-choice questions in which the user is asked several questions related to the type of lesion [
Stages of application. (a) Four-choice question in stage 1, (b) True–False question in stage 2, (c) Short answer question in stage 3, (d and e) Case questions, (f) Review in stage 5.
In the second stage, some true/false questions related to the type of lesion are displayed to the user [
The user is asked several short-answer questions in the third stage [
In the fourth stage, depending on the lesion type, one or two cases are presented, and the patient’s medical history, including clinical information, histopathology view or radiographic image, and photography related to the lesion type, are displayed [
In the fifth step, the general statistics of the test, including a general explanation, the number of questions asked, and the percentage of correct questions, are presented to the user [
After completing each exercise, users can have an overview of the exercises, including the stages, questions, and their answers, and the feedback for each question by selecting that exercise again. In the first, second, and third stages, there is a possibility for the user to skip the question. The unanswered or wrong questions of each exercise will be repeated in the next exercise [
At the end of each lesson, scoring is performed according to the user’s performance as the percentage of correct answers out of all the questions in the completed exercises. Finally, this percentage is used to compare the strengths and weaknesses of the users.
Moreover, a list of the top scores obtained by users is maintained and updated and can be displayed on a separate page for motivating students to never give up learning.
To implement the proposed application that was introduced in the previous section, the general process of software engineering has been used. According to this process, the application design starts from the “communication” phase. At this stage, the requirements and details related to the features of the application are specified. Then, in the “planning” phase, the requirements are prioritized for implementation. In the third stage of “modeling,” the software development team analyzes and designs different parts of the application according to the identified requirements and defines its structure. Then, in the fourth stage of “construction,” the application is implemented according to the design phase artifacts. Simultaneously, with the implementation of the application, its various parts have been tested, and appropriate action has been taken to fix the discovered errors. The result of this activity is an error-free application that is ready to use and available to different users in the “deployment” stage. It should be noted that new requirements may have been identified during development, so the stages of communication, planning, modeling, and construction may have been repeated several times during the project.
The content of the application questions was based on chapters 10 and 11 of Neville’s Pathology Book 2016, which was compiled by a dental student under the supervision of two professors specializing in oral and maxillofacial pathology.
To access the data, including average scores and examination answer sheets, consent was obtained from all of the participants. The application was accessible to students before the midterm and final examinations and was introduced to them as an educational tool, and they were encouraged to use it. After the midterm and final examinations, the relationship between using or not using the application and the mean score of the questions about shared topics in the lesson plan and the application was investigated. In addition, the mean score of questions about topics shared between the lesson plan and the application was compared with the mean score of questions not included in the application’s content.
Finally, a satisfaction questionnaire [
Comparison of the mean scores of questions related and unrelated to the application, considering use and not using the application
Comparison of the mean scores of questions related and unrelated to the application between students who had used the application and those who had not
Valid percentage of each question in the satisfaction questionnaire after the mid-term and final examinations
To ensure the accuracy of the results, a double-blind statistical analysis was performed (by an individual other than the study researchers). Data analysis was performed using SPSS software version 20. Paired
The mean age of the students was 21.8 ± 5.1 years, and their mean average score was 16.4 ± 2.1. Sixty-four students (57.1%) were male, and 48 (42.9%) were female. In total, 45 students (40.2%) had used the application.
In the midterm examination, the mean score of satisfaction with the application was 76.8 ± 8.6. In addition, the mean scores for questions related and unrelated to the application were 71.5 ± 15.5 and 70.4 ± 14.9, respectively.
On the midterm examination, there was no significant difference between the mean scores of questions related or unrelated to the application for the students who used the application (
The ANOVA test showed that in the midterm examination, there was no significant difference between the mean scores of questions related (
An inverse relationship existed between the age of the students and the mean scores of questions related (
The mean score for questions unrelated to the application was significantly greater for women than for men (
In the midterm, the mean score of satisfaction with the application was 76.8 ± 8.5. In addition, the mean scores of questions related and unrelated to the application were 71.5 ± 15.5 and 70.4 ± 14.9 out of 100, respectively.
The paired
The test showed that on the final examination, the mean scores for questions related to the application (
The Pearson correlation coefficient showed an inverse relationship between students’ age and the mean scores of questions related (
The independent
The frequency distribution of each question in the satisfaction questionnaire in the midterm and final examinations showed that the highest percentage of satisfaction was among the users, including easy installation and entry into the application, acceptable quality of uploaded images, successful storage of application information, relevant content of the 4-choice questions, and satisfactory experience with the content of the lesson plan and the application usage. The highest frequency of low satisfaction responses among users included reduced stress during the examination session due to using the application and improving students’ self-confidence in clinically diagnosing patients [
In the present study, the average age of the participants was 21.8 years, and most of them were men, with a mean average age of 16.4 years. After designing a learning application and its voluntary implementation for the students of the 6th semester in 2022–2023, the results of the students’ midterm examination showed that the mean score of the questions related to the application was higher for both groups of students who had used the application and those who had not. This may be related to the simplicity of the content for the midterm; however, the difference was not significant. In fact, regarding the question’s difficulty, both groups could easily identify the correct option.
The application satisfaction scores among the students who used this method were 76.8% and 74.8% in the midterm and final examinations, respectively, which was due to the innovative design of the application, the novelty of this method in education, its entertaining and challenging nature, its effectiveness in learning the lesson content, and its helpfulness in the retention of lesion tips to remember. This indicates that the application was user-friendly and that all users were relatively satisfied. In line with the present study, Arayapisit
The mean score of questions related and unrelated to the application had an inverse relationship with students’ age. In other words, with increasing age, the mean scores of questions related and unrelated to the application decreased because older students were more occupied with their occupations or family responsibilities and consequently lacked adequate time to study or were less motivated. Notably, young people are more likely to utilize technology than older people are. Moreover, the mean score of questions related and unrelated to the application was directly related to students’ average score, indicating that pathology knowledge was more important for students who had obtained higher grades in other subjects or that the importance of the grade obtained in this subject and its effect on the average score was greater for them. Accordingly, they devoted more time to studying it or were more motivated. Regarding gender, there was no significant difference in the satisfaction score with the application between male and female students, indicating that both groups of students appreciated the application, and its feedback had no relationship with their gender.
In total, 40.2% of the students used the application. Despite encouraging the students to use the application, the acceptance level of this method by the students was not as expected, which can be attributed to the low internet speed in the country, the lack of motivation to study, especially in basic courses such as oral and maxillofacial pathology, the difficulty of pathology topics, and the large amount of information materials presented. Other reasons include the short examination preparation time, the intensive midterm and final examinations, the prevailing culture of giving importance to specialized courses other than pathology, and the lack of awareness of the importance and clinical application of this knowledge in the patient examination, diagnosis, and management of pathological lesions. Approximately 57.7% of the students who used the application were female, which was probably due to female students’ greater interest in using electronic devices, greater use of educational aids by females, greater time devoted to study, and greater effort in acquiring higher scores.
The results of the final examination showed that the mean scores for questions related and unrelated to the application were significantly greater for students who had used the application, indicating that using the application familiarized students with questions and helped them answer more questions unrelated to the application in addition to more related questions [
In the final examination, age had an inverse relationship with the mean scores of related and unrelated questions, while the average score had a direct relationship with the scores for reasons similar to those of the midterm examination. Concerning the students’ gender, the mean satisfaction and related scores were greater for women than men; however, there was no significant difference. The importance of this subject’s scores and their effect on the overall average score were probably greater for female students; as a result, the motivation, effort, and study time allocated were greater.
In line with the present study, to facilitate the learning of neurology in residents, Raskurazhev
This study showed that the mean scores for questions related and unrelated to the application were greater for application users. Eighty percent of those who had used the application for the midterm examination used it in the final examination, and 9% of new users used it in the final examination evaluation. This increase could be as a reason for previous familiarity, accessibility of the application in a more extended time and its effect on the student’s grades, allocating more examination preparation time for the final examination rather than the midterm examination, and the importance of final examination grades compared to the midterm examination from the students’ point of view.
In this regard, the findings of Tsopra
Contrary to the present study, Courtier
In general, the evaluation of the satisfaction questionnaire separately in both the midterm and final examinations showed that the installation and login to the application, as well as the successful storage of information, were highly satisfactory for most users, indicating the application’s faultless design in these areas.
Furthermore, in both examinations, the content of the application questions (including four-choice, true–false, and short-answer questions and cases), which were designed under the supervision of oral pathology professors, was proportionate to the lesson plan content. The quality of the uploaded application images was acceptable according to most users. Moreover, the design of the application was appreciated by the majority of users. The impact of the application in acquiring pathology knowledge on both examinations was high for most students. Interestingly, the impact of the application in increasing students’ interest in this knowledge and learning lesson plan content was moderate to high for most individuals on both examinations. In line with the present study, a study conducted by Felszeghy
In this study, most users in both examinations found this method entertaining and challenging. Gudadappanavar
The results showed that new educational methods, such as applications, improved students’ knowledge and understanding of pathology. Fortunately, the users’ satisfaction and interest confirmed the success of the present application. Therefore, this method can be used to increase students’ learning of extensive medical science.
A recent study was approved by the research committees of the vice-chancellor in research affairs, University of Isfahan, with the number IR.MUI.RESEARCH.REC.1401.171.
The consent form was obtained from all participants, and we informed them about all parts of the study clearly.
This study was approved by the Research and Ethics Committee of Isfahan University of Medical Science and was supported financially.
The authors of this manuscript declare that they have no conflicts of interest, real or perceived, financial or non-financial in this article.
