This is an open access journal, and articles are distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 License, which allows others to remix, tweak, and build upon the work non-commercially, as long as appropriate credit is given and the new creations are licensed under the identical terms.
This is an open access journal, and articles are distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 License, which allows others to remix, tweak, and build upon the work non-commercially, as long as appropriate credit is given and the new creations are licensed under the identical terms.
The aim of this study was to evaluate clinical and radiographic success rates of 3Mixtatin and Modified 3Mix-MP paste and compare it with conventional root canal treatment procedure in primary molars requiring pulpectomy.
In this in vivo study, 66 primary molars in 52 children aged between 4 and 8 years with primary molars having chronic periapical abscess were treated randomly with 3Mixtatin, Modified 3Mix-MP paste, and Metapex. The subjects were reviewed at 6 and 12 months both clinically and radiographically after pulpal therapy to evaluate and compare the healing process. The data obtained were subjected to statistical analysis at a significance level of 0.05.
By the end of 12-month follow-up among the three groups, Group I seemed to be performing consistently better as compared to the other two groups when evaluated clinically and radiographically. However, Group III resulted in the greatest number of failures, with success rate being mere 42.9% at the end of follow-up period.
Radiographic and clinical healing occurred in all the three groups; however, based on our results, Group I seemed to be performing consistently better among the three groups at 12-month follow-up. Hence, it can be inferred that 3Mixtatin used as a localized agent is effective and comparable to both Modified 3Mix-MP paste and conventional pulpectomy procedure involving calcium hydroxide and iodoform paste in primary teeth.
Dental caries is perhaps the most prevalent chronic disease, as recognized by the American Academy of Pediatric Dentistry itself.
No procedure is perfect, every procedure has some drawbacks associated with it and pulpectomy is also one of the procedures having some demerits associated with it, these have been discussed elsewhere.
Modern pediatric dentistry always keeps seeking methods that can regenerate remaining dental tissues to save the primary teeth and maintain its functional, developmental, and esthetic capabilities.
A plethora of studies
This study was a randomized, single-blind, parallel controlled trial conducted in the Department of Pediatric and Preventive Dentistry during November 2017–April 2019, in children aged 4–8 years attending the Outpatient Department of Himachal Pradesh Government Dental College and Hospital, Shimla, participated in the study. Prior ethical approval from the Institutional Ethical Committee and consent from the parents/guardians were obtained.
Following criteria were followed for selection of teeth, children with cooperative behavior showing the following clinical characteristics were included in the study:
Spontaneous pain or tender to percussion
Deep carious lesion with pulp exposure
Presence of chronic apical abscess or sinus tract
Tooth should be restorable.
Radiographic characteristics:
Coronal-radiographic evidence of a deep carious lesions or lesion approximating pulp
Radicular discontinuity of lamina dura, furcation involvement less than or equal to half of shortest root in vertical dimension.
In addition, they include teeth involving physiological root resorption more than a third of its length or if they had the presence of obliteration of the root canal, excessive internal resorption, internal calcifications, and perforation into the bifurcation. Patients exhibiting any systemic illness or with previous history of allergy to the antibiotics used in the study were excluded from the study.
Considering α = 0.05, power = 80%, and an effect size of 0.40, a minimum sample size of 66 was required. The flow of participants undergoing the intervention was followed from allocation to the final data analysis after 12 months Flow of participants undergoing various treatment modalities.
Of the three groups, Group I comprised the 3Mixtatin group (n = 30), Group II comprised the Modified 3Mix-MP paste group (n = 29), and Group III comprised the conventional pulpectomy group receiving calcium hydroxide iodoform paste (Metapex, META Biomed Co. Ltd., Korea) as obturating materials (n = 28).
Baseline preoperative clinical and radiographic signs and symptoms were recorded on patient's history sheet including pain, presence of swelling, draining sinus, mobility, and lymphadenopathy, while radiographically teeth were evaluated for signs of periradicular changes. The teeth were later anesthetized using 2% lignocaine with 1:200,000 epinephrine (Becain-ADR, H.P., India) and isolation was done using rubber dam (a) Access opening in right maxillary second primary molar teeth, (b) Freshly Mixed 3Mixtatin paste, (c) Freshly Mixed Modified 3Mix-MP paste, (d) Triple antibiotic paste placed with in the pulp chamber, (e) Obturating the primary molar canals with prepacked syringe of calcium hydroxide and iodoform paste, (f) Restoration of primary molars with stainless steel crowns.
Preparation of 3Mixtatin paste was done by mixing three commercially available antibiotics with Simvastatin powder (Simvotin, Solrex Pharmaceuticals Co. Baddi, Solan, India). Using a sharp B. P Blade, the enteric coating of the three antibiotic tablets was removed; they were pulverized individually to fine powders using mortar and pestle. The triple antibiotics comprised 500 mg of Ciprofloxacin tablet (Ciplox®, Alchemist Ltd., India), 500 mg of Ornidazole tablet (Ornida, Aristo Pharmaceuticals, India), and 100 mg of Cefixime tablet (Cefix, Zeiss Pharma Limited, Jammu, India); these were mixed in a ratio of 1:1:1. To the above mixture 2 mg of Simvastatin powder was added, together the combination was stored in a tightly capped amber colored bottle. Since 5 mg of Simvastatin tablet (Simvotin, Solrex Pharmaceuticals Co. Baddi, Solan, India) was available commercially, the tablet was pulverized in a similar manner and weighed on an analytical scale (Sartorius Electronic Weighing Scale, BSA, New Delhi, India) with 1 mg of accuracy. Upon its clinical application, the combination powder was mixed with normal saline to form a paste
Procedure for Groups 3Mixtatin and Modified 3Mix-MP paste (lesion sterilization and tissue repair technique)
Access opening to the pulp chamber was made using a round bur mounted on a water-cooled high-speed handpiece, upon gaining access to the pulp chamber, necrotic pulp tissue if present within the chamber was removed using a sharp spoon excavator, and no attempt was made to prepare the radicular section. Using a disposable syringe, a light flow of normal saline was delivered to wash away any remaining tissue. If hemorrhage was seen to be occurring within the pulp chamber, a moist cotton immersed in 1% Sodium Hypochlorite (Dentpro©, Jammu, India) was placed until hemostasis was achieved. Freshly prepared 3Mixtatin paste was placed within the pulp chamber using a small endodontic amalgam carrier and was condensed over the root canal orifices using a moist cotton pellet.
In case of Group II, i.e., 3Mix-MP paste group, a similar procedure was followed, except the vehicle used to prepare the paste was Macrogol (M) and Propylene Glycol (P)
Clinical procedure for conventional pulpectomy receiving metapex as obturating material
Consequent to anesthetizing the tooth using 2% lignocaine with 1:200,000 epinephrine (Becain-ADR, H. P., India), isolation was done using rubber dam. An access cavity was made by a round bur mounted on a water-cooled high-speed handpiece. Pulp tissue present within the pulp chamber was removed using a sharp spoon excavator initially, later the radicular pulp was removed with a fine H-file. Thorough irrigation was done with 1% sodium hypochlorite and normal saline. The working length was determined using a diagnostic radiograph. The biomechanical preparation was done using H-Files (21 mm) in pull back motion. The canals were enlarged to two or three instrument size greater than the first file used. Simultaneously, irrigation was done using 1% sodium hypochlorite and normal saline solution. The prepared canals were dried using paper points and calcium hydroxide and iodoform paste (Metapex) was injected to fill up the canal space
Upon completion of the procedure, the treated teeth were evaluated clinically and radiographically at 6- and 12-month (a) Group I (3Mixtatin) preoperative radiograph, (b) Postoperative radiograph, (c) Radiograph at 6-month interval, (d) Radiograph at 12-month interval, (e) Group II (Modified 3Mix-MP paste) Preoperative Radiograph, (f) Postoperative Radiograph, (g) Radiograph at 6-month interval, (h) Radiograph at 12-month interval, (i) Group III (calcium hydroxide iodoform paste) preoperative radiograph, (j) Postoperative radiograph, (k) Radiograph at 6-month interval, (l) Radiograph at 12-month interval.
Radiographic images were evaluated by the operator and an examiner for the above criteria's. To assess intrarater agreement, 4 weeks after the first session, the operator again scored all the study images. While for the interrater agreement, scores were assigned individually by both the examiners and evaluated to Cohen's kappa analysis. Those cases in which consensus could not be reached unanimous agreement were made by both the operator and the examiner.
The treatment outcomes were analyzed based on clinical and radiographic findings, data were tabulated and recorded as preoperative and follow-up findings both clinically and radiographically. The radiographic evaluations were carried out by two co-investigators. Cohen's kappa statistic for intra- and inter-examiner reliability was 0.886 and 0.891, respectively, which indicates almost perfect agreement. Categorical variables were reported as counts and percentages. Group comparisons were made using the Chi-square test or Fisher's exact test. P < 0.05 was considered significant. All the statistical tests were two-sided and were performed at a significance level of α = 0.05. Analyses were conducted using IBM SPSS STATISTICS (version 22.0, IBM, Chandigarh, India). The distribution of tooth type in the sample is shown in
Postoperative clinical findings
All the teeth present in the groups were evaluated clinically at 6- and 12-month intervals. Among the total 87 primary molars, 66 primary teeth contributed to a follow-up of 1 year with 21 teeth resulting as dropout cases. Of these 66 primary molars, 34 were primary first molars and 32 were primary second molars among these teeth, nine teeth depicted signs of pain and increased mobility in which four teeth contributed to Group II while Group III had five teeth contributing to 23.8% failure clinically at 6-month interval. Furthermore, the teeth showing clinical signs of failure had risen at 12-month interval in which Group I had 2 teeth showing signs of pain and swelling, while Group II had additional 2 teeth with pain and mobility adding up to six in total teeth showing clinical signs of failure, although these findings were statistically insignificant. In Group III, teeth with clinical signs of failure had risen from five teeth to ten teeth making 47.6% of total failure. These findings were statistically highly significant (P = 0.005) when comparing teeth at 6- and 12-month intervals in Group III. The comparison among the groups is seen in Depicts clinical success and failure among three groups at 6- and 12-month intervals.
Postoperative radiographic findings
All the teeth present in the groups were evaluated radiographically at 6- and 12-month intervals. Although when the teeth were evaluated within individual groups at 6- and 12-month intervals, more failure of teeth was seen radiographically in Group III in comparison to Group I and Group II and the findings were statistically insignificant. However, due to increased periapical radiolucency and external root resorption manifesting in Group III, its comparison to Group I and Group II showed statistically significant differences during intergroup analysis. These are shown in Depicts radiological success and failure among three groups at 6- and 12-month intervals.
Signs and symptoms exhibited by a tooth reflect its status of vitality. Understanding of the mechanism that protects, controls, and regulates resorptive process may help in maintaining a primary tooth as long as it is necessary. Thus, the rationale of this study was to preserve the primary teeth with pathological interradicular or periapical root resorption by targeting the undifferentiated mesenchymal cells leading to osteoblast differentiation and activation. Moreover, application of antibiotics topically to eliminate bacterial contamination and reduce inflammation is warranted as it serves as the main cause of treatment failure in primary teeth. LSTR is a technique which facilitates not only disinfection of the canal but also serves as an equivalent to conventional pulp therapy.
In addition, in Group I, the combination used, i.e., 3Mixtatin, incorporates Simvastatin, an antihyperlipidemic drug, into the triple antibiotic paste, Simvastatin was used as an anti-inflammatory and bioinductive agent, whereas 3Mix served as an antibacterial agent. The bioinductive effects of simvastatin result in inhibition of bone resorption and promotion of osteoblast proliferation and differentiation.
Although on reviewing literature, a number of studies have made comparison among various triple antibiotic combinations using the LSTR technique. However, only one studies by Aminabadi et al. uses 3Mixtatin to treat interradicular or periapical root resorption and/or perforation in primary molars and it reported a high clinical and radiological success rate of 96.9% at the end of 12 months.
While comparing Modified 3Mix-MP paste (Group II) to studies in the literature, our study showed a clinical success of 82.6% and 73.9% at 6- and 12-month intervals, while the radiographic success was 74% and 61%, respectively. A study by Raslan et al.
In our study, Group III seemed to be underperforming, as the clinical success when compared to studies by Nurko and Garcia-Godoy
The findings of our investigation have led to a paradigm shift in the pupal treatment of primary teeth as 3Mixtatin had significantly proven more successful when compared to Modified 3 mix-MP paste and conventional root canal therapy. However, such conclusive inference should be weighed against limitations such as small sample size and great number of lost follow-up. Further studies are warranted to develop substantial evidence for use of 3Mixtatin in a more generalized practice.
Within the limits of present in vivo study, we concluded the following:
3Mixtatin paste can be considered effective and superior pulp therapy agent using LSTR technique when compared to calcium hydroxide paste in primary teeth On the basis of the overall success rates at 12-month follow-up of all the three medicaments, the following order of performance can be inferred:
Clinical performance: 3MIXTATIN > MODIFIED 3MIX-MP PASTE > CALCIUM HYDROXIDE AND IODOFORM PASTE Radiographic performance: 3MIXTATIN > MODIFIED 3MIX-MP PASTE >> CALCIUM HYDROXIDE AND IODOFORM PASTE.
Financial support and sponsorship
Nil.
Conflicts of interest
The authors of this manuscript declare that they have no conflicts of interest, real or perceived, financial or non-financial in this article.
Clinical significance
Statins are class of drugs with proven bone regenerating potentials and a viable treatment options in retaining primary molars with poor prognosis until physiologic exfoliation Calcium hydroxide and iodoform paste may result in exaggerated inflammatory response when used in primary molars undergoing severe inflammatory process.